Greetings Fellow Comstoks! ([info]fengi) wrote,
@ 2006-10-10 15:56:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Nerd Post AND Identity Politics Post
The last time I wrote about Heroes the Japanese Nerd Who Can Warp Space And Time made me uncomfortable. I will admit I was a bit too quick and harsh to judge this. His character has been fleshed out and his less nerdy friend is now his sidekick. More importantly, the guy who plays the character is a big nerd who works for Industrial Light and Magic when he isn't doing comedy. I think my discomfort was slightly valid, but comparing him to Mickey Rooney was a straight up racist way of being politically correct and I apologize.

The show overall is much better than what one expects from Network TV taking on a comic book plot - i.e. not sabotaging the fantastic plot elements so they can focus on "character drama" which they think has wider appeal (yes, this is a Lost reference). They seem to have realized: 1. There are character driven plots, but character cannot exist outside of plot. 2. Most shows are fantastic in terms of huge plot holes - if audiences can accept Horatio Caine's Sunglasses Of Brooding Justice, they can handle dudes who fly.

HOWEVER

In episode three the story about The Indestructible Cheerleader involves an attempted rape as a key plot point. Three episodes and the two main female superheros have both been violently sexually assaulted.

I'm sorry, but that shit is fucked up.


(Post a new comment)


[info]ludickid
2006-10-10 09:09 pm UTC (link)
Yeah, violent abuse of the female heroes! Someone's been consulting with Geoff Johns.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]archaica
2006-10-10 09:26 pm UTC (link)
Beat me to it.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]morchades
2006-10-11 03:45 am UTC (link)
Okay, now I'm curious. When have Johns ever used sexual assault or threat of it with a female victim? I mean, I've heard the theory about Sand and Johnny Sorrow, but I really can't think of anything close happening in Stars and STRIPE, Green Lantern (he did just retcon a statutory rape out of continuity in the last issue), Teen Titans, IC, or JSA with a female character.

Was this during his Avengers run?

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]stopword
2006-10-10 09:15 pm UTC (link)
I think it's an epidemic this season. Seems like there's something in the air. Catherine on CSI, Alex on Criminal Intent, the chick on Criminal minds got shot in a somewhat erotic way (weird how they pull that off). Combined with the weird extra-misogyny incidents in the news (amish, montreal, and the other school shooting that targeted women/girls in a sexual and fatal way) I feel like I need to watch my back more than normal.

(Reply to this)


[info]g0jir0
2006-10-10 09:37 pm UTC (link)
Yeah, at first I was okay with it, because I thought both attempted rapes fit the situation. But now that I think about it, last night's was just to stick the branch into the chick's head so she could wind up on the slab. That could have been achieved some other way, given they'd already had a rape attempt in the pilot.

I would like to believe, though, that this was just lazy writing and not latent mysogeny. I'm a Pollyanna like that.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]fengi
2006-10-10 10:42 pm UTC (link)
I agree it's the largely result of lazy writing, but it makes me wonder about the creators when sexual violence is used as an easy moment of intense drama. Such scenes should be carefully prepared by story and tone. The attempted rape was lengthy and explicit, and while this show is "dark" it is a network fantasy and hasn't earned the narrative strength to pull off such an ugly moment. Although given the number of rapes and assaults on Bruckheimer shows, it's easy to see why they'd think it wasn't a big deal.

(Reply to this) (Parent)

suspending both disbelief and analysis
[info]alexparker
2006-10-10 11:38 pm UTC (link)
I've been watching, and honestly, I'm riveted. But I am also a comic book fan and fucked enough in the head that I would be willing to martyr myself in order to have superpowers and do something spectacular. I don't think, though, that just the females have it badly [although they do. Porn Mom makes no sense, has no likeability, and just generally is poorly thought out and acted. I'm hoping they have bigger plans for her that will unfold as time goes by, but I worry that they won't.] Flying Boy desperately wants to be a sympathetic character, but he's too wishy washy to really get in to. Junkie Artist is so incredibly one-sided that I don't think it's possible for them to give him any sort of relatability. Hiro is adorable, yes, but I'm wondering when he's going to figure out that he's causing a lot of the problems, and what that's going to do to him. He also seems to have no backstory whatsoever. He's also the only one whose name I've learned. The only main characters I like are the Cop Who Can Hear Thoughts, Indestructable Cheerleader, and Professor's Son. The cop, in just two episodes, has done far more than most of the others with less to do it with. The cheerleader has the relatability with most of the audience in that she just wants to be normal and not have to deal with being a superhero. As for the professor's son...I don't know. Maybe I just have a crush on him. I like me some smart boys.

While I can easily point out for hours the problems with this show, it doesn't change the fact that, while I'm watching it, I am completely enthralled. I turn into a little [fan]girl and just watch. And when it's over, I go, "Okay, that was awesome."

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: suspending both disbelief and analysis
[info]fengi
2006-10-11 03:09 pm UTC (link)
See I like the show a great deal and this doesn't prevent me from watching it, but that rape attempt bothered me. The point was to have her get "killed" so she could end up in the morgue.

The injury and waking up were gruesome and cartoony - the assault was disturbingly realistic in length and intensity, with the overhead shot of him forcing himself upon her. I don't know how you do a rape lightly, but it just seemed unecessary - considering he accidentally snapped her neck with a tackle the week before I think they could have found some other way for her to die - like she tells him off and he pushes her down. Still violence from a creepy boyfriend, but without the rape part.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)

Re: suspending both disbelief and analysis
[info]alexparker
2006-10-12 01:22 am UTC (link)
And I completely understand what you're saying, and don't necessarily disagree. It is fucked up that both the female characters have been sexually assaulted, and it wasn't necessary or seemingly explained on the cheerleader's part. But honestly, females are sexually assaulted pretty frequently. I remember when I left for college, I didn't know anyone who had been assaulted, and within a few weeks of school, about 3/4 of the girls I knew had a story. I, personally, haven't been, [knock on wood], but I attribute that to the fact that 1, I'm paranoid and terrified, and as such constantly vigilant and avoidant, and 2, straight boys are scared of me. So somehow, it didn't even occur to me that they had both been assaulted.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…